Home > Articles > Data > SQL Server

  • Print
  • + Share This
This chapter is from the book

Determining Normal Forms

As designers and developers, we are often tasked with creating a fresh data model for use by a new application that is being developed for a specific project. However, in many cases we are asked to review an existing model or physical implementation to identify potential performance improvements. Additionally, we are occasionally asked to solve logic problems in the original design. Whether you are reviewing a current design you are working on or evaluating another design that has already been implemented, there are a few common steps that you must perform regardless of the project or environment. One of the very first steps is to determine the normal form of the existing database. This information helps you identify logical errors in the design as well as ways to improve performance.

To determine the normal form of an existing model, follow these steps.

  1. Conduct requirements interviews.

    As with the interviews you conduct when starting a fresh design, it is important to talk with key stakeholders and end users who use the application being supported by the database. There are two key concepts to remember. First, do this work before reviewing the design in depth. Although this may seem counterintuitive, it helps prevent you from forming a prejudice regarding the existing design when speaking with the various individuals involved in the project. Second, generate as much documentation for this review as you would for a new project. Skipping steps in this process will lead to poor design decisions, just as it would during a new project.

  2. Develop a basic model.

    Based on the requirements and information you gathered from the interviews, construct a basic logical model. You'll identify key entities and their relationships, further solidifying your understanding of the basic database design.

  3. Find the normal form.

    Compare your model to the existing model or database. Where are the differences? Why do those differences exist? Remember not to disregard the design decisions in the legacy database. It's important to focus on those differences, because they may stem from specific denormalization steps taken during the initial design, or they may exist because of information not available to the original designer. Specifically, identify the key entities, foreign key relationships, and any entities and tables that exist only in the physical model that are purely for relationship support (such as many-to-many relationships). You can then review the key and non-key attributes of every entity, evaluating for each normal form. Ask yourself whether or not each entity and its attributes follow the "The key, the whole key, and nothing but the key" ideal. For each entity that seems to be in 3NF, evaluate for BCNF and 4NF. This analysis will help you understand to what depth the original design was originally done. If there are many-to-many relationships, ensure that 5NF is met unless there is a specific reason that 5NF is not necessary.

Identifying the normal form of each entity in a database should be fairly easy once you understand the normal forms. Make sure to consider every attribute: does it depend entirely on the primary key? Does it depend only on the primary key? Is there only one candidate primary key in the entity? Whenever you find that the answer to these questions is no, be sure to look at creating a separate entity from the existing entity. This practice helps reduce redundancy and moves data to each element that is specific only to the entity that contains it.

If you follow these basic steps, you'll understand what forms the database meets, and you can identify areas of improvement. This will help you complete a thorough review—understanding where the existing design came from, where it's going, and how to get it there. As always, document your work. After you have finished, future designers and developers will thank you for leaving them a scalable, logical design.

  • + Share This
  • 🔖 Save To Your Account