- May 6, 2005
Six Significant Information Security Challenges
Executives need to understand and address six significant challenges, which are listed here and reviewed in detail in the following sections:
- E-commerce requirements
- Information security attacks
- Immature information security market
- Information security staff shortage
- Government legislation and industry regulations
- Mobile workforce and wireless computing
The Internet has created an important channel for conducting business called electronic commerce (e-commerce). This channel provides many new ways for businesses to offer products and services to their customers. In the past, the ability to connect with millions of customers 24 hours a day, 7 days a week was only possible for the largest corporations. Now even a company with limited resources can compete with larger rivals by offering products and services through the Internet with only a modest investment. E-commerce services are quite appealing to consumers who do not want to spend their limited free time in traditional retail stores constrained by normal business hours of operation, unfriendly staff, and long checkout lines. Executives must understand how to leverage this new channel of electronic commerce while managing the associated risks.
Companies now rely on the Internet to offer products and services according to their customer's buying preferences. The Internet is no longer an optional sales method but rather a vital distribution channel that a business cannot ignore. Figure 1-2 provides a summary of commerce conducted electronically in 2002.
Figure 1-2 Growth in electronic commerce.
Pioneering companies such as eBay and Amazon have revolutionized the easy purchase of products through the Internet. Not only is it easy for customers to purchase their products, but also companies have innovated the use of concepts such as “personalization” to create unique relationships with individual customers. Using personalization, companies are able to identify their online customers by name, offer products based upon previous buying habits, and safely store home address information to make purchasing online much quicker. These strategies have enabled successful e-commerce companies to create a positive shopping experience without the overhead associated with traditional retail stores.
Retail securities is another industry that has been transformed as a result of the Internet. In the past, a stockbroker might charge a few hundred dollars to trade a thousand shares of stock. Now a consumer can use an online brokerage firm and complete the same trade for less than twenty dollars. This has revolutionized the securities industry by providing a much more cost-effective service to their customers. It has also put a large number of retail stockbrokers out of work.
Along with increased capabilities come some new challenges that businesses must overcome to be successful. For instance:
- Companies are under tremendous pressure to deliver these systems as quickly as possible because being first to market with a new capability can be a great competitive advantage.
- Timely and accurate access to information for employees, customers, and partners is no longer nice to have—it is expected.
- Companies must offer these services in an easy-to-use but completely secure manner because they store confidential information such as home addresses and personal credit card numbers.
- The systems are expected to be available 24 hours a day, 7 days a week because customers expect to be able to access the products and services at their convenience, not the company's.
These challenges place considerable demands on IT organizations because delivering these e-commerce systems in a timely and secure manner is very difficult. As expectations increase, so do the demands on the systems and technology.
Constant Growth and Complexity of Information Security Attacks
Security incidents that are related to malicious code (worms, viruses, and Trojans) have grown from slightly annoying to significantly damaging to business operations. A computer virus is a piece of malicious code that attaches to or infects executable programs. Unlike worms, viruses rely on users to execute or launch an infected program to replicate or deliver their payloads. A virus' payload can delete data or damage system files.
A Trojan (named after the Trojan horse in Greek mythology) is a malicious program disguised as something innocuous, often a utility or screensaver. Like viruses, Trojans rely on unsuspecting users to activate them by launching the program to which the Trojan is attached. Trojans have many functions; some delete or steal data, whereas others install backdoors that enable a hacker to take control of a system. Unlike viruses, Trojans do not replicate.
Early computer viruses were often contained to individual users' systems, resulting in only a small decline in staff productivity for a given day. However, present-day blended threats, such as Code Red and Nimda, present multiple security threats at the same time, causing major disruptions and billions of dollars of damage to enterprises. A blended threat combines different types of malicious code to exploit known security vulnerabilities. Blended threats use the characteristics of worms, viruses, and Trojans to automate attacks, spread without intervention, and attack systems from multiple points. Figure 1-3 puts things in perspective by illustrating the economics of these attacks over the past few years.
Figure 1-3 Worldwide malicious code impact.
These attacks now cause losses of billions of dollars each year, so businesses can no longer ignore the problem. The Love Bug Virus in 2000 had an impact of $8.75 billion alone, causing businesses to finally recognize viruses as a significant issue and to begin to broadly implement anti-virus solutions. This work has lowered the losses experienced since that year; however, the impacts continue to be significant.
Theft of proprietary information is also a major risk to information security. When intellectual property (IP) is in an electronic form, it is much easier to steal. If this information is stored on computers connected to the Internet, thieves can potentially steal it from anywhere in the world. According to the 2003 CSI/FBI Computer Crime and Security Survey, theft of IP remains the highest reported loss. Two recent high-profile examples include an operating system product for a major software company and a version of an operating system for a major networking company. The software company theft was from an authorized third party, whereas the networking company appears to have been compromised by an unauthorized intruder. These types of security problems will only get worse as the Internet continues to grow in usage and complexity.
Three major issues have fueled the growth in security incidents: the increased number of vulnerabilities, the labor-intensive processes required to address vulnerabilities, and the complexity of attacks.
Vulnerabilities are holes or weaknesses in systems that a hacker can exploit to attack and compromise a system. For example, a system administrator can forget to limit certain restricted privileges to authorized users only. This would be like giving everyone on your street a key to the front door of your house when you only meant to give one to your family members. Other examples include existing vulnerabilities resulting from defects in computer software. In these situations, the software vendor should have identified and resolved these weaknesses during the testing processes but overlooked them while under pressure to ship new products by a deadline.
The software industry's solution to these vulnerabilities is to provide fixes in the form of software patches that a company's staff must apply to “patch” the “hole.” The process of testing these patches and applying them to your environment is labor-intensive. It is often quite difficult to address the highest-level vulnerabilities and the staggering growth of new vulnerabilities compounds this problem. Vulnerabilities reported in 2003 grew by 300% from those reported in 2000. Figure 1-4 summarizes the number of CERT reported vulnerabilities over the past few years.
Figure 1-4 Security vulnerabilities reported.
The complexity of security attacks has greatly increased over the past few years. The early viruses caused individual productivity issues, but they had nowhere near the impact of blended threats such as Code Red or Nimda. As we mentioned earlier, blended threats use a combination of attack vectors—five in the case of Nimda—to spread more rapidly and cause more damage than a simple virus. For example, Code Red infected 350,000 computers in just 14 hours. In January 2003, the Slammer Worm hit the Internet and had an even higher infection rate than Code Red, infecting 75,000 machines in less than 10 minutes of its release.
The fastest-spreading mass-mailing worm to date was MyDoom in January 2004. At the height of the outbreak, more than 100,000 instances of the worm were intercepted per hour. MyDoom relied on people to activate it and enable it to spread. Cleverly disguised as an innocuous text file attachment, unsuspecting users opened the attachment and launched the worm.
The rapid spread of these threats makes it increasingly difficult to respond quickly enough to prevent damage. Figure 1-5 provides a look at the evolution and growing magnitude of these threats over the past few years:
Figure 1-5 Worldwide attack trends.
The threats are expected to continue to grow in magnitude, speed, and complexity, making prevention and clean-up even more difficult. These factors contribute to the need for a proactive plan to address information security issues within every company.
Immaturity of the Information Security Market
The information security market is still in its infancy, with few formal standards established for products or services. The best way to characterize this market would be to compare it to the enterprise resource planning (ERP) market in the early 1980s. Companies at that time were purchasing finance, order processing, and manufacturing systems from separate vendors and having their IT staff integrate these products. This was a time-consuming and expensive process because no standards existed, and interoperability between different vendors was poor. The market then matured, and a small number of vendors such as SAP emerged as industry leaders. These leaders provided a complete solution for companies that included all the individual systems as part of their integrated ERP system. They also established the standards for smaller companies offering complementary functionality. Smaller companies either met the industry leader standards or were pushed out of the market.
The information security industry is at a similar stage today, with several companies offering individual solutions such as firewalls that address only a portion of a company's security needs. As a result, their customers face the challenge of making all these solutions work together. Only early versions of standards exist, forcing companies to complete multiple installations of “point” solutions that provide individual components of their security systems.
As with the ERP systems, this will change as a small number of vendors emerge as leaders and offer complete solutions that can support the majority of a company's information security needs. Smaller niche players in the market will integrate their products with these leaders' standards because their customers will no longer be willing to have their IT staff perform this role. However, until this day comes, the IT staff continues to bear the daunting task of cobbling all these solutions together. They must deploy a constantly expanding list of products and complete the integration work to ensure that these components are working together.
Another significant challenge that IT technicians face is the sheer amount of data they need to absorb to understand and manage the current state of their computing environment. Each product generates alarms, logs, and so on that they must review to determine whether something is wrong. Figure 1-6 provides a graphic overview of this situation.
Figure 1-6 Information security hierarchy.
Security products generate a great deal of data; however, only a small number of problems or “incidents” might be affecting the company. It is difficult for security staff to get an overall picture of the security environment and put plans in place to address the critical concerns. This is similar to the business challenge in the 1990s when executive information or decision support systems were developed to mine through large volumes of data to determine critical business trends. Several vendors now offer decision support systems to address this issue for business executives. The “holy grail” for the information security industry is to develop similar systems to solve this problem in the security arena.
An additional challenge is the relative low priority that the software industry places on security. Although some leaders in the software industry have announced a new emphasis on security, the majority of the industry has yet to follow this example. They currently focus on making software easy to use and are under tremendous pressure to deliver new products and services, often sacrificing security. This results in the growing number of vulnerabilities. Until the software industry receives more pressure to prioritize security, even at the sacrifice of new features, this situation will continue.
It will take some time for information security vendors to offer mature solutions to protect your business. In the meantime, you must develop strategies to mitigate these risks. The good news is that the security industry is following a similar pattern to other enterprise software industries, so solutions will be forthcoming.
Shortage of Information Security Staff
Finding qualified information security staff is a difficult task, which will likely continue to be the case in the near future. Driving the hiring challenge is the immaturity of the solutions from information security vendors, the limited number of qualified staff available, and the unique blend of information security skills required. Business executives will need to invest more in this area to overcome these challenges.
Due to the immature market, lack of standards, and numerous point solutions, training is a problem for security staff. The industry has not had the time to grow the staff necessary for these roles. In addition, the information security challenges keep growing at a rapid pace, constantly expanding the list of technology to be deployed, and the information security staff just can't keep up. This translates into more time and money to get your staff trained on commercially available products.
According to the only available survey by CSOOnline.com in 2002, only 60% of the companies responding have an employee who is fully dedicated to information security, and only 32% of those individuals hold a senior-level title such as chief information security officer or chief security officer. These are relatively new titles for most, with an average of two and a half years of experience as head of information security. With the increased focus on information security, we can expect these numbers to increase in the near future.
Obtaining the necessary credentials for information security requires considerable training and experience. The Certified Information Systems Security Professionals (CISSP) credential is an internationally accredited certification and requires passing a test on a broad range of information security topics combined with a minimum of four years of work experience. The related System Security Certified Practitioner (SSCP) credential requires one year of experience plus passing an exam.
Certified Information Security Manager (CISM) also requires a minimum number of years of information security experience along with successfully passing a written exam. All these certifications require ongoing annual training as part of their certification, and GIAC requires periodic testing every two years. Security professionals holding these certifications are in high demand, and employers will need to compete to attract them to their companies. Certified Information Systems Auditor (CISA) requires a minimum of five years of work experience before sitting for an exam. SANS Global Information Assurance Certifications (GIAC) requires candidates to submit a practical work assignment as part of their certification. Certified Information Security Manager (CISM) also requires a minimum number of years of experience.
In addition to specific technical training, information security staff members need to develop security enforcement skills that are not part of the traditional IT staff background. The military, intelligence, and law enforcement fields have traditionally conducted training in this area. In some respects, a company's security policies are similar to “laws” that must be enforced within a company, which requires specialized training. This unique requirement makes it difficult for existing IT staff to transition into information security roles without receiving specialized enforcement training.
Probably the greatest challenge in this area is finding a leader who has a broad background in the field and who can pull together an effective information security team. Few candidates have been in the information security field for more than a couple of years and have the required blend of technical and security enforcement skills. They also face the leadership challenge of taking inexperienced staff and developing them into effective information security professionals while dealing with ever-increasing security risks. These individuals are rare and in high demand.
Executives will need to consider longer-term strategies to address these needs because finding trained staff is not just a question of money but also of the time necessary to build the team around a limited number of qualified staff.
Government Legislation and Industry Regulations
Recent information security incidents and increased reliance upon the Internet have prompted governments around the world to create additional legislation to regulate the technology ecosystem. This legislation spans broad areas, such as consumer privacy, to specific regulations for industries, such as health care and financial services. Because the Internet is easily accessible from many places in the world, it is important to understand and operate in compliance with these regulations. Companies that adhere to these regulations and thereby offer their customers a safe and secure method for conducting business can differentiate themselves from their competitors.
Privacy is a major issue in electronic commerce due to the high risk of misuse of personal information. Computer systems contain personal information for millions of customers, and if companies do not take the necessary precautions to ensure that this information is safe and secure, their customers can have their identities—including data such as name, address, phone number, and credit card numbers—stolen and sold to the highest bidder on the Internet. Previously, only a highly skilled hacker could break into these systems and access confidential information. This is no longer the case; now a novice can use readily available tools and gain access into these systems if the company does not use the proper safeguards.
This situation has prompted considerable legislation to protect the rights of consumers because their personal information is now much more readily available in electronic format. The European Data Protection Directive is an important regulation because Europeans take a much stricter view of privacy than the United States.
This directive prohibits the export of personal data such as name, address, and telephone number to countries that do not meet the European Union's minimum standards for consumer privacy protection. These standards require that no one can sell, rent, or transfer consumer data to a third party without that individual's explicit permission. This directive applies to customer information but also includes employee information contained in companies' internal human resource systems.
In May 2000, the Safe Harbor Agreement was enacted for U.S. companies that are regulated by the U.S. Federal Trade Commission (FTC) and have operations in the European Union. This agreement enables these organizations to comply with the European Data Protection Directive by adopting Safe Harbor Agreement Principles.
These principles require controls to ensure that personal information is protected from loss, misuse, unauthorized access, disclosure, and so on as a condition to obtain certification. Companies certified under the Safe Harbor Agreement can obtain permission to transfer data out of the European Union for renewable one-year periods. It is safe to say that other countries will adopt similar legislation for protecting the privacy of consumer information for their respective citizens.
An important consideration for business executives to remember is that laws and regulations are generally enacted on a country-by-country basis and electronic commerce is performed globally. As soon as your business uses the Internet to conduct business, you are doing business on a worldwide basis. This has the tremendous advantages of offering your products and services globally; however, you also need to comply with local regulations. These regulations are by no means consistent, and you could easily find yourself conflicting with one regulation by complying with another. The Safe Harbor Agreement is an example of the U.S. working out an agreement with the European Union to meet their regulations. Other countries will follow similar strategies to ensure that their industries are competitive and that they can operate freely in major markets such as the European Union.
One major challenge is that certain countries do not place a high priority on protection of personal information or intellectual property. They might have more pressing issues, such as food or medicine, and might be unwilling or unable to police individuals who are engaged in activities such as software piracy. These criminals operate freely in these countries without the fear of law enforcement agencies shutting down their operations. These safe havens for cyber criminals pose additional challenges for legitimate businesses that have little legal recourse to combat the illicit activities of software pirates. Unless business executives put strategies in place to protect their intellectual property and customer information, they run the risk of falling victim to these individuals.
HIPAA proposes to streamline the healthcare industry, reduce fraud, and make it easier for employees to switch jobs even if they have preexisting medical conditions. One of the key objectives is to standardize and automate key administrative and financial transactions that previously were paper-based. HIPAA establishes standard data formats for these transactions and the controls that must be in place to ensure that this information is secure. To ensure the privacy and confidentiality of patient's medical records, it institutes standards for the privacy of individually identifiable health information. All companies handling medical data must adhere to HIPAA requirements for privacy—not just companies within the healthcare industry. These organizations will need to review these regulations in detail to ensure that they are in compliance.
The Sarbanes-Oxley Act is a response to the corporate corruption and failure of many companies during the Internet boom and subsequent bust that occurred during the 1999–2002 period. This U.S. law went into effect in July 2002 and is intended to protect investors by improving the accuracy of corporate disclosures. All U.S. public companies must meet financial reporting and certification mandates for all financial statements filed after June 15, 2004. Smaller companies and foreign corporations that are publicly traded in the U.S. market must meet these regulations for any statements filed after April 15, 2005.
The act is divided into 11 titles, and section 404 that addresses internal controls has generated the most concerns. The act calls for severe penalties for non-compliance, including the possibility of criminal prosecution for executives. From an information security perspective, it is difficult to achieve compliance under Sarbanes-Oxley without having an effective information security program to protect your vital financial information. Adequate controls must also be implemented to ensure that only authorized individuals are able to access this information. Change control processes must also be in place to ensure that any changes to your financial systems are implemented in a controlled manner. Finally, you need to have a business resumption program in place to ensure that your organization can continue to operate in the event of a disaster. Access and change control are covered in more detail in later chapters, whereas business resumption is beyond the scope of this book.
California Senate Bill (SB) 1386 went into effect in July 2003 and requires companies that conduct business in California to disclose any breach of security related to personal data. This law applies to both business and government agencies that own or license computerized data containing personal information. Security breaches include unauthorized access of computer data that compromises the confidentiality or integrity of personal information. Personal information includes social security numbers, driver's license numbers, and account, credit, or debit card numbers. Written or electronic notice must be given to individuals who are affected by this breach of security.
For companies doing business on the Internet, the implications of SB 1386 are far-reaching for information security because many of these businesses have customers in California and are therefore subject to SB 1386. Public notification of these security breaches can be embarrassing to companies and can have a direct impact on their brand and revenue stream. Penalties can be imposed on organizations that do not comply with the notification requirements. These regulations place additional importance on having an effective information security program in place for any company that plans to leverage the Internet to conduct business.
These are just a few examples of government and industry regulations that can affect how a company conducts business electronically. With the growing number of e-commerce security incidents, the number of regulations will continue to grow. When you start conducting business through the Internet, you are operating on a global basis and must conform to laws and regulations in many different countries. It is important to understand these laws and the restrictions that they can pose. Health care and financial services companies must give special consideration because they have specific regulations with which they must comply. Successful business executives will develop strategies that turn these challenges into competitive advantages.
Mobile Workforce and Wireless Computing
The arrival of mobile computing devices has had a significant impact on everyday life. Wireless communications liberate employees and consumers from relying on phone lines to communicate. Looking for a phone booth to make a call or going to the office to access email is quickly becoming a fading memory. Information availability and communications have greatly increased due to mobile computing devices. With the convenience of these devices, information security concerns increase because the confidential information stored on them needs to be protected.
In the past, staff members typically used one computer in the office for business purposes and a different one at home for personal use. These lines have blurred considerably over the past few years, with the use of mobile computers now surpassing the number of desktop computers that remain in a home or office. Laptop computers now enable employees to continue working at any time from any location. Personal computing devices for storing name and address information, phone numbers, and so on are no longer restricted to business professionals because teenagers now keep track of this information using mobile devices. Figure 1-7 provides some insight into current and projected usage of wireless users.
Figure 1-7 Wireless Internet usage and projections.
The introduction of the 802.11 protocols for wireless local area networking in 1999 has revolutionized the mobile computing industry. The 802.11 protocols are the equivalent of a common “language” that enables these mobile devices to communicate with each other. Wireless adapters that take advantage of the 802.11 protocols are available for mobile devices. In some areas, wireless ISPs have begun offering high-speed Internet access without the need for phone lines or a cable connection. Accessing the Internet, sending email, and logging into the company network is now possible from the home, backyard, or your favorite park.
The challenge from a security perspective is twofold—first, all the protection offered in the company office must now be incorporated on the laptop computer or mobile device, and second, 802.11 protocols have weak security features. When physically in the office, employees can take advantage of the company's security protection such as firewalls and anti-virus software. These products can be set up to operate in the background, and employees often do not realize that these products continually protect their systems from threats such as computer viruses. When employees leave the office, this same protection must be included on notebook computers or handheld devices to ensure that they can continue to operate in a safe and secure manner. In addition to the lack of information security tools, mobile devices that might contain valuable intellectual property, customer information, or other sensitive information also run the risk of theft or loss.
New technologies often initially focus on features and functionality at the expense of security to obtain critical mass and adoption. This is the case of 802.11, as individual consumers have initially embraced this technology and are less concerned with someone reading their email or obtaining access to their personal address book. Businesses, on the other hand, cannot take those risks because enterprise systems contain vital company records that could disrupt their operations if divulged to unauthorized parties. Companies must give careful consideration before leveraging wireless technology in mainstream business.
These information security risks include all the mobile devices such as cell phones, personal digital assistants, and so on that contain valuable information. As a result, companies need to ensure that their information security program extends to all devices that frequently leave the office and that are easily lost or stolen. They can no longer count on safely locking computers in the offices when employees go home at night. Wireless communication offers many compelling advantages over traditional wired communications, but controls must be in place to ensure that the company's most valuable secrets are secure.